"Eric Schulte" <schulte.eric@gmail.com> writes:

> Hi Julien,
>
> Thanks for the patch, however it looks like the attached patch breaks
> columnname support for R source code blocks.  I'm pasting in the
> relevant portion of our test suite, from the development.org file in our
> development repository [1].  Could you please sort this issue out before
> we apply the patch?

Hi Julien,

Thanks for the patch and for raising this issue. It's been something
I've wanted to sort out for a while.

I'm attaching a rushed-together org file containing some test examples
for colnames and rownames. I think it shows a couple of problems with
your patch, but I had to do this quickly so sorry if I'm mistaken.

Before we finalise the behaviour, I'd like us to be clear about the
following issues:

1. When we say ':rownames yes', are we
   1. Declaring that the input has rownames?
   2. Declaring that we want the output to have rownames?
   3. Both?
2. Same as (1) but for colnames

I've added the test file to our devel repo at 
http://github.com/eschulte/babel-dev/
please contact either of us offline for access to the repo.

Could we use this org file as the basis for settling on final
colnames/rownames behaviour in org-babel-R?

Dan